Not sure where to post this but very intresting



As a former scout and the parent of a current cub scout, I am horrified at the prospect of an MPAA-sponsored “Respect Copyright” merit patch to be dangled as an incentive before kids right here in SoCal, in local LA troops no less.


Of course, it’s not the first time that I’ve been troubled by the decisions of scouting policy makers. Certainly, I was hacked off by the fact that the leadership has stripped even the littlest scouts of their religion insignia if it was earned from activities involving my centuries old religion that included many of the founding fathers, just because my faith shows more respect for the individual lifestyle choices and committed unions of gays and lesbians than the BSA does. (The major religion in question even developed a separate scouting curriculum to try to solve the conflict.)


After reading a story about a somewhat similar scout-sponsored piracy prevention program in Hong Kong, readers may remember that Mel Horan and I jokingly crafted some nifty mock-ups of possible patches to be used, should the program come here to the States. This was a gag, however. Never in my wildest dreams did I imagine that it would actually happen. How could such a one-sided, moralistic, anti-consumer marketing effort be foisted on a bunch of earnest and community-minded kids?


So now we’ve made up a new patch, for a much more challenging “Free Culture” badge, to be earned by intrepid, hard working, patriotic scouts. Here are some of the requirements:


* Appear at the door of a major studio, dressed in your full scout uniform, and try to talk them into allowing educational use of historical films commonly shown in public schools (Amistad, Schindler’s List, etc.)

* Raise money with a bakesale to go across the country to CMG Worldwide in Indianapolis or Intellectual Properties Management (IPM) in Atlanta to convince these organizations to free images associated with Rosa Parks or Martin Luther King and release them into the public domain for use in school projects, such as web pages

* Paint a colorful mural on a graffiti covered wall across the street from the headquarters of the RIAA with the 9 Reasons Digital Media Products Are a Bad Deal for Consumers.

* Using your knot-disentangling skills, visit a hospital or nursing home and help the aged with their DRM-hobbled digital products

* Go to an orphanage, battered children’s home, or juvenile detention facility and show kids how to use Creative Commons resources

* Put in 100 hours of community service at your local library and see the toll that new legislation against patron privacy and public connectivity takes on your local civil servants. Then imagine what it will be like if they have to deal with RIAA and MPAA lawsuits for circulating audio and video content.




This is old news that dates back to 2006. I don’t think the proposal went anywhere, otherwise we all would have traded for them by now. The original badge was under consideration by the Hong Kong Scouts in 2005 as an “intellectual property rights” badge sponsored by the MPAA. It was later picked up in the US as a “merit badge” under consideration by the Los Angeles Area Council, but it was clearly only a pocket patch all along.

By ISCA87L on October 16th, 2009 at 5:29 am

Well never saw it listed here, and i found about it looking for something else…

By redneck_patch_trader on October 16th, 2009 at 5:41 am

Leave a Reply



Search this website

DISCLAMER: It is not officially affiliated with the Boy Scouts of America, the Girl Scouts of the USA or the World Organization of Scout Movements.