A great piece of Scouting history surfaced this week in the Scout Patch Collectors Facebook group, and it’s too good to let the timeline bury it.
Andy Cogswell posted a photo of a dark blue felt arched strip embroidered in gold: NEW YORK CITY — STATEN ISLAND. He’d picked it up at an antique store for very cheap, and ChatGPT had put it somewhere between 1941 and 1954. He asked the group if anyone knew more.

The New York City – Staten Island shoulder strip Andy Cogswell found in an antique store. Photo: Andy Cogswell, via the Scout Patch Collectors Facebook group.
Gene Berman did. Gene is one of the longtime Greater New York Councils collectors in the group, and his answer is the kind of knowledge you can’t find in a catalog. Here’s what he shared:
New York City was the first council to have the full-size shoulder strips. Starting in 1941, seven color combinations were produced over the years, each matching a program’s uniform: blue with gold letters for Cub Scouts, khaki and red for Boy Scouts, blue and white for winter Sea Scouts, white and blue for summer Sea Scouts, blue-on-blue for Air Scouts, and green with brown letters for Explorers. In 1953, everyone except the Sea Scouts switched to red and white strips — the seventh color.
Five boroughs plus Greater New York Councils made six issuing entities. Six entities times seven colors means 42 possible patches in theory. But Greater New York Councils never produced strips for Cubs, Scouts, Explorers, or Air Scouts, which brings the real total down to 38. Gene has 34 of them in his own collection.
The ones still on his want list tell their own story: he needs a Sea Scout navy blue with white letters like the one Andy posted, and Air Scout blue-on-blue strips for Manhattan, the Bronx, and Queens. He already has Staten Island and Brooklyn in Air Scout blue-on-blue, but no blue-on-blue is known for those other three boroughs — they may simply never have produced them. He also needs a Staten Island in Sea Scout blue and white, which he knows exists.
For the council’s 75th anniversary, Greater New York Councils issued a souvenir set of all 42 — including the four that were never actually made during the period of use.
The red and white strips were phased out beginning in 1970, replaced by CSPs. The first New York City CSPs were issued in July 1974.
That’s the kind of knowledge that lives in the comments of the Scout Patch Collectors group, and it’s worth preserving. Thanks to Andy for posting the strip and to Gene for sharing what he knows. You can see the original discussion in the Scout Patch Collectors Facebook group: https://facebook.com/groups/323868214332022/permalink/29654881690803952/
As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase.
Comments
Close